many Cherokees don’t agree.
When my Cherokee friends and I discussed it, some of the comments made were:
“Last I heard, cowboys killed Indians for fun!”
“He is truly out of touch with the Cherokee people.”
“That is in very poor taste.”
“If he has no clue why this is offensive, then he really is just a white man playing Indian.”
“It sounds like, for $1500, you can play a Native. Come on down and get that Native experience!”
“He’s making a mockery of us!”
And this isn’t all Cherokees have said about the topic of “Cowboys and Indians.” In a post from the popular blog, Native Appropriations, the Cherokee writer said,
“…it’s clear there are large similarities between blackface and playing Indian–both are intentional acts that draw upon stereotypes and a racist history to enact whiteness–but our Nation has created a narrative in which blackface=racist, while redface=normal.
Does that make it ok to play Indian or host a cowboys and Indians theme party? Absolutely not. It just goes to show how deeply the erasure of Native peoples runs. Just because our national narrative and history has somehow normalized the phenomenon does not excuse its roots in the process of systematic erasure of the First Peoples from our homelands.”Also in his song, "My Land", the Cherokee, Litefoot, rapped,
“Let’s play cowboys and Indians, it’s sad, why? Cause the Indian is always the bad guy.”Personally, I don’t know how ANY Indian, let alone the chief of an Indian nation, could think that having a “Cowboys and Indians” themed fund raiser is okay. The term “cowboys and Indians” brings to mind the old westerns where cowboys were the heroes (think John Wayne) while Indians were portrayed as blood thirsty savages out to kill white people. Is this the image Cherokees want associated with them? I can't speak for us all, but I don't like it. I think it is a shame that we have a chief that is so disrespectful to Indian people and all the things our ancestors suffered throughout history.
I wonder, will Chief Baker attend this fund raiser playing a cowboy, dressed in Cinch jeans, Lucchese boots and a Resistol hat, or will he go as an Indian? And if he plays an Indian, will he be wearing stereotypical buckskins and feathers or will he go for that "tucked in ribbon shirt" look he is well known for? Enquiring minds want to know.
Those are my thoughts for today.
Thanks for reading.
copyright 2013, Polly's Granddaughter - TCB